vohraandvohra.com

Bombay High Court Restores Design Infringement Injunction in Atomberg v. Stove Kraft: The Importance of the ‘Eye Test’ Under the Designs Act, 2000

Bombay High Court Restores Design Infringement Injunction in Atomberg v. Stove Kraft: The Importance of the ‘Eye Test’ Under the Designs Act, 2000

The Bombay High Court has reinforced the importance of assessing the overall visual appearance of a registered design, holding that minor differences between competing products cannot automatically defeat an infringement claim.

Introduction

In a significant development in Indian design jurisprudence, the Bombay High Court, in Atomberg Technologies Private Limited v. Stove Kraft Limited, Commercial Appeal (L) No. 14941 of 2026, delivered on 16 October 2026, restored interim protection in favour of Atomberg Technologies Private Limited. The Division Bench of Justice Bharati Dangre and Justice Manjusha Deshpande set aside an earlier order refusing interim relief and restrained Stove Kraft from manufacturing, selling, marketing or otherwise dealing in ceiling fans that infringed or imitated Atomberg’s registered design.

The judgment reiterates that design infringement must be assessed through the overall visual impression created by competing products. Courts should not reduce the comparison to a feature-by-feature exercise in which isolated differences overshadow the essential visual characteristics of the registered design. The decision also examines the distinction between the tests applicable to assessing the validity of a registered design and those relevant to determining infringement.

Background of the Dispute

Atomberg Technologies is the registered proprietor of Design Registration No. 325322-001, registered on 1 January 2020 in Class 23-04 in respect of a ceiling fan. The design was applied to its Renesa range of ceiling fans, including the Atomberg Renesa Alpha.

Atomberg alleged that Stove Kraft Limited had introduced its “Pigeon fan-tastic BLDC Ceiling Fan”, which substantially imitated the shape, configuration and overall visual appearance of Atomberg’s registered design. According to Atomberg, the distinctive elements included:

  • Petal-inspired, elongated fan blades with a distinctive curved appearance.
  • Asymmetrical tapering of the blades, with one side tapering more than the other.
  • A subtle V-shaped bend along the length of the blades.
  • A curved fan body that narrows towards the top and gradually widens towards the bottom.
  • Canopies with slanted top edges, creating a continuous and balanced visual appearance.

Atomberg maintained that the combination of these features gave its ceiling fan a distinctive aesthetic appeal and that Stove Kraft had adopted a substantially similar design to benefit from the reputation and commercial success associated with Atomberg’s product. Atomberg instituted Commercial (IP) Suit No. 710 of 2025, seeking a permanent injunction, damages of ₹110 crore or, alternatively, an account of profits, along with other reliefs.

Procedural History: From Interim Protection to Appeal

On 24 July 2025, the Bombay High Court granted Atomberg ex parte ad-interim protection and appointed a Court Receiver to search for and take possession of the allegedly infringing products.

On 17 April 2026, the learned Single Judge dismissed Atomberg’s interim application, holding that the company had failed to establish a prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable injury. The Court also discharged the Court Receiver and directed the release of the seized goods.

The Single Judge had compared individual components of the competing fans, including their blade designs, motor housing lids, shank profiles, rivet quantities and canopies. On this comparison, the Court concluded that the products were substantially different. Atomberg appealed, placing before the Division Bench the question whether the competing fans had been assessed using the correct legal standard for design infringement.

Legal Framework: Protection Under the Designs Act, 2000

The dispute primarily concerned the protection available to a registered design under the Designs Act, 2000. Section 2(d) defines a design in terms of features of shape, configuration, pattern, ornament or composition of lines or colours applied to an article, which in the finished article appeal to and are judged solely by the eye. The definition excludes methods or principles of construction and features that are purely functional.

Section 4 prohibits the registration of designs that are not new or original, have been disclosed to the public before the relevant filing date, or are not significantly distinguishable from known designs or combinations of known designs. Section 22 addresses piracy of registered designs and provides remedies against unauthorised application, imitation and dealing in infringing articles.

Design protection concerns the aesthetic appearance of an article. It does not confer a monopoly over ordinary functional features necessary for the product to perform its intended purpose. The novelty of a design may reside in the combination of its features rather than in every individual component considered separately.

The Division Bench’s Key Findings

1. Overall Visual Impression Must Prevail Over Isolated Differences

The Division Bench rejected an excessively fragmented comparison of the rival products. It observed that the Single Judge had concentrated on individual differences instead of examining the overall visual appearance and the essential features responsible for the design’s distinctive identity.

The Court clarified that competing designs need not be exactly identical for infringement to be established. The relevant question is whether the essential visual features of the registered design have been substantially reproduced in the allegedly infringing product. It identified the essential features of Atomberg’s design as the petal-shaped elongated blades, their tapering towards the ends and their attachment to the canopy.

The Court found that the competing products, when examined as a whole, displayed substantial visual similarity. Minor differences in individual components, dimensions or materials could not, by themselves, defeat the infringement claim.

2. The ‘Eye Test’ in Design Infringement

The judgment places considerable emphasis on the ‘eye test’, which requires the Court to compare competing products through their overall visual appearance. The comparison should reflect the perspective of an ordinary purchaser who encounters the products in the marketplace and may carry an impression of the original product’s distinctive appearance.

If another product reproduces substantially similar visual characteristics, the purchaser may mistake it for the original. Design infringement therefore cannot be determined merely by identifying technical differences between individual components. The essential inquiry is whether the overall visual impression of the registered design has been substantially imitated.

3. Distinction Between the ‘Instructed Eye’ and the Ordinary Consumer

The Court explained that the instructed eye is relevant when examining whether a design is new or original in comparison with prior art. A person familiar with existing designs and common trade variations is better placed to assess whether the claimed design possesses sufficient novelty.

The infringement inquiry serves a different purpose. For infringement, the Court considered the perspective of the ordinary purchaser, who may be misled by the substantially similar appearance of two products. The purchaser need not possess technical knowledge of earlier designs or understand the precise features that made the registered design novel.

  • Novelty and originality: Whether the design is new or original when compared with prior art, assessed through an informed or instructed perspective.
  • Infringement: Whether the allegedly infringing product substantially imitates the registered design when assessed through its overall visual appearance and from the perspective of the ordinary purchaser.

The legal question of whether a design qualifies for registration is therefore not identical to the question of whether another product infringes that registered design.

4. Novelty Can Reside in a Combination of Features

The Court clarified that a registered design need not claim novelty in every individual feature. Atomberg’s case was based on the combination of the shape and configuration of the blades, the fan body and the canopy; it did not claim an independent monopoly over every component.

The Court noted that the Z-shaped shaft relied upon by Stove Kraft was not a feature in which Atomberg had claimed novelty. Emphasis on that particular feature could not determine the comparison between the registered design and the impugned product. The scope of design protection must be understood by reference to the features in which novelty is actually claimed and the overall design represented in the registration.

5. Passing Off and Likelihood of Confusion

Apart from design infringement, Atomberg had also alleged passing off. The Court recognised that a passing-off action does not require proof of actual confusion. It is sufficient to establish a likelihood that purchasers may be misled into believing that the defendant’s product originates from, or is commercially connected with, the plaintiff.

In assessing this issue, the Court considered the goodwill associated with Atomberg’s ceiling fans, their market presence and the overall visual similarity between the competing products. The Court found that the substantial similarity in shape and configuration, together with the circumstances of adoption, supported Atomberg’s claim of passing off at the interim stage.

Final Decision of the Bombay High Court

The Division Bench held that the Single Judge had failed to apply the correct legal test while comparing the competing ceiling fans. Accordingly, the Court:

  1. Set aside the order dated 17 April 2026 refusing interim relief.
  2. Allowed Atomberg’s Interim Application No. 88 of 2026.
  3. Restored the interim injunction restraining Stove Kraft and persons acting on its behalf from infringing or imitating Atomberg’s registered design.
  4. Restrained the defendant from manufacturing, selling, marketing, distributing, advertising or otherwise dealing in ceiling fans bearing an identical or deceptively similar shape, configuration or design.
  5. Restored the earlier order appointing the Court Receiver.

The decision concerns interim protection pending the final disposal of the underlying suit. It is not a final adjudication of all issues, including the ultimate determination of damages or the final liability of the defendant.

Implications for Design Protection and Indian Businesses

First, the overall design matters. Businesses seeking to protect product aesthetics should identify and document the combination of features that creates the distinctive visual identity of their products.

Second, registration representations are important. The drawings and views submitted during design registration help define the design for which protection is claimed. Businesses should ensure that these representations accurately capture the intended features of novelty.

Third, minor alterations may not be sufficient. A competing manufacturer cannot necessarily avoid infringement merely by changing a few dimensions, components or technical details if the essential visual characteristics of the registered design remain substantially reproduced.

Fourth, evidence of commercial goodwill remains valuable. Sales records, advertising materials, product launches and evidence of continuous market presence can support passing-off claims alongside statutory design protection.

Finally, businesses should consider intellectual property protection at the product-development stage. Design registration, supported by appropriate documentation and a clear understanding of the features claimed as novel, can become an important part of a company’s commercial strategy.

Conclusion

The Bombay High Court’s decision in Atomberg Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. Stove Kraft Ltd. reinforces the principle that design infringement is fundamentally concerned with visual imitation and the overall appearance of a product.

By distinguishing the instructed-eye assessment of novelty and originality from the ordinary purchaser’s perspective in infringement proceedings, the Court has provided useful guidance on the application of the Designs Act, 2000.

The judgment also serves as a reminder that intellectual property protection extends beyond brand names and trademarks. The visual identity of a product can itself represent significant commercial value, and registered designs provide a statutory mechanism for protecting that value against unauthorised imitation.

For manufacturers and businesses investing in product innovation, the decision highlights the importance of securing design registrations and protecting the distinctive aesthetic features that differentiate their products in the marketplace.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Disclaimer

As per the rules of the Bar Council of India, advocates and law firms are prohibited from soliciting work or advertising.

By clicking on “I Agree”, the user acknowledges that there has been no advertisement, solicitation, or inducement by our firm. The user is accessing this website voluntarily for informational purposes only.

The information available on this website does not constitute legal advice and shall not create any lawyer-client relationship. Any material downloaded or information obtained is entirely at the user’s discretion and volition.

By proceeding further, the user accepts the terms of this disclaimer.